Changing the stock speaker can result in a significant change in tone. However, you need to understand the specs before attempting to buy a replacement speaker for your guitar amp. Similarly, you cannot connect a head amp to an external cabinet without knowing the rating first.
Speaker voicing
Guitar speakers are not designed
to produce a flat response like audiophile speakers. Hi-fi speakers are flat
because you want to reproduce the original recording as much as possible.
Guitar speakers, on the other hand, are used to create music, and colorization
contributes to the resulting tone. Tone colorization occurs when certain
frequencies of the original signal are either boosted or cut, changing the
shape of the original sound.
When choosing a speaker, it is
important to determine the voicing you want to achieve. If you want the clean
tone from vintage Fender amps, then look for American voicing. If you want modern
Marshall or Vox sound, then look for British voicing. Among the popular brands,
Celestion is known for British tone, and Eminence for American tone.
Speaker size
Sound is produced by the speaker
cone pushing air. A bigger cone will push more air than a small one. An 8”
speaker will push less air, resulting in a thinner sound. A 15” speaker, on the
other hand, will push more air, resulting in more bass. Imagine what four 12”
speakers can do!
If you can afford only one amp,
choose one with a 12” speaker. Do note that bigger speakers come with big
magnets, making them much heavier than a small one. When replacing existing
speakers, take note of the depth of the stock speaker. Some speakers are deep
and may hit other components when used as replacement.
Usual speaker sizes are 8”, 10”,
12”, and 15”.
Speaker distortion
Speaker distortion refers to the
speaker sound breakup when pushed hard and beyond the clean output threshold.
When done in a controlled manner, the resulting distortion can enhance the tone
from the amp. You cannot force speaker breakup if the amp’s power rating is
much lower than the speaker’s power handling capability. Some guitarists use
speakers with lower power rating to create early speaker breakup, but this can
result in a blown speaker if not handled carefully.
Speaker breakup threshold does not
depend on the power rating of the speaker. They are dependent on the materials
and design used by the speaker. Two different speakers with 50 watt rating can
have different breakup thresholds.
Impedance matching
It is quite important that the
amplifier impedance match the speaker impedance. An 8-ohm amp must be connected
to an 8-ohm speaker. A mismatched pair can result in the amp having a hard time
driving the speaker, or a speaker blowing because it is driven too hard. A 50
watt, 8-ohm amp at maximum will put out only 25 watts to a 50-watt speaker with
16-ohm impedance. Conversely, a 50-watt, 8-ohm amp will put out 100 watts to a
50-watt speaker with 4-ohm impedance and probably blow it.
Impedance matching is
straightforward for single-speaker cabs. However, there are several factors to
consider when using multiple speakers in a single cabinet.
Cabinets with two speakers
What sounds bigger, a single 12”
speaker or two 10” speakers?
Installing two speakers in a
single cabinet results in more volume of air being pushed, resulting in a
bigger sound. How they are wired, however, can affect the effective impedance,
and power rating.
You can wire your speakers two
ways, series or parallel. Series wiring is if the positive terminal of speaker
A is connected to the negative terminal of speaker B. The free terminals of
each speaker are then connected to the input jack’s positive and negative
terminals. In a series connection with the same impedance for both speakers,
you can get the effective impedance by multiplying by two.
Two 4 ohm speaker = 8 ohms
Two 8 ohm speaker = 16 ohms
Two 8 ohm speaker = 16 ohms
In a parallel connection, the
positive terminals of each speaker are connected to the positive terminal of
the input jack. Similarly, the negative term terminal of each speaker is
connected to the negative terminal of the input jack. In a parallel connection, the effective
impedance is computed by dividing by two.
Two 8 ohm speaker = 4 ohms
Two 16 ohm speaker = 8 ohms
Two 16 ohm speaker = 8 ohms
The effective power of a cab with
two speakers is computed by multiplying the power rating of each speaker by two,
if they have the same rating. If the speakers have different power ratings,
multiply the lower rating by two.
Two 50 watts = 100 watts total
One 25 watts + one 50 watts = 2 x 25 = 50 watts total
One 25 watts + one 50 watts = 2 x 25 = 50 watts total
Suppose you have a 100-watt, 8-ohm
head amplifier, you have the following options for an external speaker cabinet:
One 100-watt, 8-ohm speaker
Two 50-watt, 4-ohm speakers wired in series
Two 50-watt, 16-ohm speakers wired in parallel
One 50-watt, 4-ohm speaker + One 80-watt, 4-ohm speaker wired in series
One 50-watt, 16-ohm speaker + One 80-watt, 16-ohm speaker wired in parallel
Two 50-watt, 4-ohm speakers wired in series
Two 50-watt, 16-ohm speakers wired in parallel
One 50-watt, 4-ohm speaker + One 80-watt, 4-ohm speaker wired in series
One 50-watt, 16-ohm speaker + One 80-watt, 16-ohm speaker wired in parallel
Speaker cable
Do not use instrument cables to
connect the amp to the speaker cabinet. Though the jacks look the same, the
current passing through the wires is much greater and can melt the wires of an
instrument cable. A gauge 14 speaker wire is safe for this purpose.
/royc
* Images are from Tom's Guitar Manila
Very informative as usual, Roy. Bass players now gravitate towards multiple 10 inch speakers giving a more tighter, more defined bottom. A few years ago, the bigger the better (15 inch). Things change. Impressions change. It's a very subjective world.
ReplyDeleteI agree that 10" speakers are more balanced and with a tighter bass. I would have wanted a 2x10 instead of a 1x12 if I have space in the house.
ReplyDelete